The ranking of universities and colleges at the national global level is a well-known doubtful practice. Imperfect approaches generate inaccurate results of these institutions. Nowadays, prestigious (有威望的) law and medical schools have started to walk away from this “evaluation”.
There are two obvious methodological problems with all of this. One is that the numerical rankings suffer from false precision. Is there really a difference between No.10 and No.11 in the undergraduate (本科生) school rankings? Johns Hopkins University famously had a plan called“10 by 20”with the goal of getting to No.10 by 2020. Hopkins is a great undergraduate institution — whether it’s No.10 or No.11 is meaningless, but it did indeed make it into the top 10 ahead of schedule, which no doubt delighted its trustees and students.
The other methodological problem is that rankings reward those schools that promote measurements by admitting students who have had the advantages of better pre-college education and test preparation coaching, and whose wealth will make them likely future donors. Equally worthy applicants without such resources will fail to enter the schools.
The good news is that in recent months, a reckoning (清算) has begun. Last September, Columbia University chose not to participate in the undergraduate rankings after an enterprising professor discovered that the school was fudging its own numbers. If Columbia’s data were corrected, it would drop from No. 2 to No. 18. Two months later, law schools began pushing back. Yale and Harvard Law Schools announced that they would refuse to provide data to U. S. News, and several outstanding law schools followed suit.
This resistance to rankings has now begun in the world of science. This is a great sign. In announcing its decision, the dean of Washington University’s medical school said, “…it is time to stop participating in a system that does not serve our students or their future patients.”
1. Why does the author mention Johns Hopkins University?A.To share an experience. | B.To give specific example. |
C.To make a detailed comparison. | D.To illustrate a complicated concept. |
A.Its data was not based on facts. |
B.It was left behind by other universities. |
C.It didn’t think the system served their students. |
D.Other universities chose to refuse to participate in the rankings. |
A.Objective. | B.Indifferent. | C.Supportive. | D.Opposed. |
A.Resistance to Educational Rankings |
B.The Ranking of Universities and Colleges |
C.Educational Rankings: Scientific or Imperfect |
D.Reasons for Universities’ Refusal of Rankings |
相似题推荐
【推荐1】Some chimpanzees(黑猩猩)are much wilder when it comes to making beats, scientists have discovered. In a Ugandan rainforest, the chimps have developed their own drumming(击鼓)styles on tree roots. Researchers observed their drumming styles range from rock to jazz. One chimpanzee brought back the style of the late John Bonham, a drummer who played a piece of music, Whole Lotta Love, and is ranked as one of the best. “The chimpanzee makes very fast drums with many evenly separated beats. His drumming is so fast that you can hardly see his hands.” said Catherine, leading scientist of the study.
Drumming with feet and hands with their special calls is used to exchange messages through thick forests, even with miles between them. Ben the Alpha’s call was a close two quick beats and a distant third, sometimes fourth.
Catherine also said. “We could often recognize which chimpanzee was drumming, and it was a fantastic way to find the different ones we were looking for. So if we could recognize, we were sure they could.”
The team was surprised to note the chimpanzees only used their personalized drumming styles when on the move, showing that the chimpanzees could decide whether to be recognized or not. The research could also settle a problem about why these chimpanzees greet each other when they meet but are not observed to say goodbye when they part in the forest. “The chimpanzees don’t need to say goodbye because they’re effectively able to keep in touch.” Catherine said. These long-distance signals give the chimpanzees a way to recognize with each other.
The researchers’ next study will be to explore whether different drumming styles can lead to different drumming cultures among the different chimpanzee populations.
1. What do we know about the chimpanzees in the first paragraph?A.Their drumming styles are too fast to discover. |
B.Their own drumming styles have been formed. |
C.Their wild drumming styles are ranked as the best. |
D.Their drumming styles are in various music forms. |
A.By performing different styles of calling. |
B.By beating the drum quickly on tree roots. |
C.By combining drumming and special calls. |
D.By using their personalized drumming styles. |
A.Because they don’t want to be recognized. |
B.Because they don’t want to see each other. |
C.Because they are on the move all the time. |
D.Because they have their own way to contact. |
A.The Chimps—singers in their special voices |
B.The Chimps—drummers in personalized styles |
C.The Chimps interested in making musical beats |
D.The Chimps delighted in performing with hands |
【推荐2】You’re walking down a quiet street and suddenly you hear some footsteps. Undoubtedly, it means that there’s someone around. But have you ever wonder why it occurs to us that it’s someone else’s footsteps, not ours?
According to a new study published in the journal Nature in September, this phenomenon arises from a function in our brain to ignore the noise we make ourselves.
In order to explore how our brain does this, a group of scientists carried out an experiment with mice at Duke University. The research entered on an intuition(直觉)—that we are usually unaware of the sound of our own footsteps—as a vehicle for understanding larger neural(神经系统的) phenomena; how this behavior reveals the ability to monitor, recognize, and remember the sound of one’s own movements in relation to those of their larger environments.
In the experiment, research controlled the sounds of a group of mice could hear, reported Science Daily. During the first several days, the mice would hear the same sound each time they took a step. This was just like “running on a tiny piano with each key playing exactly the same note”, senior study author Richard Mooney, a professor of neurobiology at Duke University, told Live Science.
Scientists found that their auditory cortex (听觉皮层) – the area of the brain that processes sound – became active at first but decreased its response to the sound after two or three minutes when the mice became familiar with it.
“ It’s almost like they were wearing special headphones that could filter(过滤) out the sound of their own movements.” David Schneider, an assistant professor at the Center for Neutral Science at New York University, told HuffPost.
But once the sound changed, their auditory cortex became active again. This suggests that the “sensory filter” in a mouse’s brain could help it detect new sounds or abnormal noise in the environment easily after tuning out familiar sounds.
“For mice, this is really important,” said Schneider. “They are prey animals, so they really need to be able to listen for a cat creeping up on them, even when they’re walking and making noise.
Being able to ignore the sounds of one’s own movements is likely important for humans as well. But the ability to predict the sounds of our own actions is also important for more complex human behaviors such as speaking or playing an instrument.
“When we learn to speak or to play music, we predict what sounds we are going to hear – such as when we prepare to strike keys on a piano – and we compare this to what we actually hear, ”explains Schneider. “We use mismatches between expectation and experience to change how we play – and we get better over time because our brain is trying to minimize these errors.”
1. What can be discovered about mice in the experiment?A.Their brain responds inactively to the familiar sounds |
B.They are able to detect sounds other animals don’t notice. |
C.They cannot identify different sounds except their own footsteps. |
D.Different areas of their brain are responsible for different sounds. |
A.Getting used to abnormal or unfamiliar sounds. |
B.Ignoring the sounds made by our companions. |
C.Identifying the sounds from a larger environment. |
D.Being sensitive to the sounds of our own movement. |
A.He has the ability to match the wrong note with the instrument player. |
B.He has an intuition that he should ignore the sound of his own movement. |
C.He has a low expectation and knows where players are likely to make errors. |
D.He has a good prediction of how each note should be played in the orchestra. |
A.Noise-filtering ability ensures us a quiet and undisturbed environment. |
B.The ability to ignore familiar noises helps to detect potential dangers. |
C.The activeness of auditory cortex determines our activity performance. |
D.Sound-predicting ability seems not so important for humans as for animals. |
【推荐3】As climate change quickly advances, many Middle Eastern countries aremaking the change from oil-based economies to ones that attract people fromaround the world--for travelling, business, work or to live.
One such example is NEOM to be built in Saudi Arabia. A key part of NEOM is “The Line”, a $725 billion futuristic city designed to house 9 millionpeople. It is a mirrored (镜子) wall-like building 200 meters wide and 500 meterstall. To be built in north-western Tabuk province, the project will spread 170 kilometres from the Red Sea across deserts, mountains and valleys.
At first look, the project appears environmentally impressive. The city area isno more than 100 metres from any point in the city. A high-speed electric publictransport service makes sure every part of “The Line” is within 20 minutes away. Unluckily, as in many high-rise buildings with a large population inside, a vertical (垂直的) transportation would be needed, for it is just like a 125-floor building.
The project costs also seem OK at $55,000 per person. Let’s say this isachievable in a country like Saudi Arabia and only covers infrastructure (基础设施). Even so, it remains to be seen how super-high-speed transport and mostadvanced infrastructure and services within the hugest building ever built can becost-effective.
The Line is planned for green living. Energy comes from renewable sources,waste water is reused, and it owns the latest “smart city” and mixed-use buildingtechnologies. Car ownership is avoided in favour of walking, cycling and publictransport.
However, the materials to be used and the building of such a big projectcould be very harmful to the environment. The plan says no one would be morethan two minutes from nature. But does this include the waiting times for a liftWithout careful design, a high dependence on vertical transportation may ruin thepleasure of walkable or bicycle-friendly areas.
1. Why will “The Line” be built in Saudi ArabiaA.To take a step towards green economies. |
B.To attract more tourists from all over the world. |
C.To house the increasing population in Saudi Arabia. |
D.To make preparations for a project known as NEOM. |
A.By showing an example. | B.By designing drawings. |
C.By making a comparison. | D.By supplying numbers. |
A.It will surely cost S725 million to build. | B.It will be wholly environmentally friendly. |
C.It will require a vertical transportation. | D.It will be a 125-floor building for certain. |
A.Unclear. | B.Doubtful. |
C.Indifferent. | D.Hopeful. |
【推荐1】At some point in our lives, most of us have attended a school or university lecture. These learning sessions give us some insightful and valuable knowledge or can be something we yawn through, trying to keep awake. Whatever our experience, lectures have been and still are the most common teaching method in education. But will they exist in the future?
With the growth of the Internet and so much information at our fingertips, you may think there is no need to gather together at a fixed location holding a handful of textbooks. BBC journalist Matt Pickles says, “Research has shown that students remember as little as 10 percent of their lectures just days afterwards.”
Professor Carl Wieman, who campaigns against the traditional lecture, felt talking at students and expecting them to absorb knowledge was not that effective so he introduced “active learning” that encourages problem solving in small groups. He listens to them and guides their discussions. The result has improved exam results. Other new alternatives to the lecture have included peer-to-peer learning and project-based learning that enable students to link up and work cooperatively on projects such as building a computer game.
But new learning methods can come at a high financial cost compared to the relatively cheap way of being taught face to face by an academic. The real issue according to Professor Dan Butin, founding dean of the school of education and social policy at Merrimack College in Massachusetts, is that “Academics put thousands of hours of work into their books and much less time into thinking about the effectiveness of their teaching style.” But he says, “The lecture has survived because research, not teaching, determines the success of a university and its academics.”
So if research quality is a measure of a university’s success and money is tight, then the lecture could be here for a little longer.
1. What may Matt Pickles agree with?A.Students have a poor memory. |
B.Students don’t work hard enough. |
C.Lectures are not so effective as expected. |
D.The Internet offers far more information than lectures. |
A.Teaching projects. | B.Learning strategies. |
C.Alternatives to lectures. | D.Ways of communication. |
A.They promote active learning. | B.They call for the least memory work. |
C.They determine the success of a university. | D.They contribute to academic achievements. |
A.By analyzing data. | B.By listing opinions. |
C.By making comparison. | D.By concluding general rules. |
【推荐2】Education affects all aspects and stages of human life. From the moment we are young children, education is a part of our daily life. Monday through Friday we sit in classrooms learning and studying various topics until we graduate from high school.
While graduation is an exciting time in a person's life, there is also a negative side which some graduates seem to experience post-college.
As symptoms are not always so obvious or miserable, some graduates don't realize they are in a state of depression. But they may feel tired, or restless, lose interest in life and become unable to enjoy anything, find it hard to make decisions, and even have difficulty in sleeping
With college graduation approaching, many students have idealistic hopes about life after the diploma.
A.hor many it is on to university. |
B.Some college graduates suffer from depression. |
C.They are always preparing for finals and graduation. |
D.During university years, students feel powerful and important. |
E.They expect to get hired into a top position at their dream company. |
F.If you think you are suffering from depression, talking to a psychologist. |
G.Avoiding people and losing self- confidence are also some of depression's symptoms. |
Any society which is interested in equality of opportunity and standards of achievement must regularly test its pupils. The standards may be changed—no examination is perfect — but to have no tests or examinations would mean the end of equality and of standards. There are groups of people who oppose this view and who do not believe either in examinations or in any controls in schools or on teachers. This would mean that everything would depend on luck since every pupil would depend on the efficiency, the values and the purpose of each teacher.
Without examinations, employers will look for employees from the highly respected schools and from families known to them--- a form of favoritism will replace equality. At the moment, the bright child from ill-respected school can show certificates to prove he or she is suitable for the job, while the lack of certificate indicates the unsuitability of a dull child attending a well-respected school. This defence of excellence and opportunity would disappear if examinations were taken away, and the bright child from a poor family would be a prisoner of his or her school’s reputation, unable to compete with the child from the favored school.
The opponents of the examination system suggest that examinations are an evil force because they show differences between pupils. According to these people, there must be no special, different, academic class. They have even suggested that there should be no form of difference in sport or any other area: all jobs or posts should be filled by unsystematic selection. The selection would be made by people who themselves are probably selected by some computer.
1. The underlined word “favoritism” in paragraph three is used to describe the phenomenon that _______.
A.bright children also need certificate to get satisfying jobs. |
B.children from well-respected schools tend to have good jobs. |
C.poor children with certificates are favored in job markets. |
D.children attending ordinary schools achieve great success. |
A.Schools for bright children would lose their reputation. |
B.There would be more opportunities and excellence. |
C.Children from poor families would be able to change their schools. |
D.Children’s job opportunity would be affected by their school reputation. |
A.jobs should not be assigned by systematic selection. |
B.computers should be selected to take over many jobs. |
C.special classes are necessary to keep the school standards. |
D.schools that win academic subjects should be done away with. |
A.schools and certificates. | B.examination and equality. |
C.opportunity and employment. | D.standards and reputation. |